unless a man could show a good reason for writing verse； it was rather
against him； and a proof of weakness。 I suppose this severe conclusion
was something he had reached after dealing with innumerable small poets
who sought the light in him with verses that no editor would admit to
print。 Yet of morbidness he was often very tender； he knew it to be
disease； something that must be scientifically rather than ethically
treated。 He was in the same degree kind to any sensitiveness； for he was
himself as sensitive as he was manly； and he was most delicately
sensitive to any rightful social claim upon him。 I was once at a dinner
with him； where he was in some sort my host； in a company of people whom
he had not seen me with before； and he made a point of acquainting me
with each of them。 It did not matter that I knew most of them already；
the proof of his thoughtfulness was precious； and I was sorry when I had
to disappoint it by confessing a previous knowledge。
VIII。
I had three memorable meetings with him not very long before he died： one
a year before； and the other two within a few months of the end。 The
first of these was at luncheon in the summer…house of a friend whose
hospitality made it summer the year round； and we all went out to meet
him； when he drove up in his open carriage； with the little sunshade in
his hand； which he took with him for protection against the heat； and
also； a little； I think； for the whim of it。 He sat a moment after he
arrived； as if to orient himself in respect to each of us。 Beside the
gifted hostess； there was the most charming of all the American
essayists； and the Autocrat seemed at once to find himself singularly at
home with the people who greeted him。 There was no interval needed for
fanning away the ashes； he tinkled up before he entered the house； and at
the table he was as vivid and scintillant as I ever saw him； if indeed I
ever saw him as much so。 The talk began at once； and we had made him
believe that there was nothing egotistic in his taking the word； or
turning it in illustration from himself upon universal matters。 I spoke
among other things of some humble ruins on the road to Gloucester； which
gave the way…side a very aged look； the tumbled foundation…stones of poor
bits of houses； and 〃Ah；〃 he said； 〃the cellar and the well？〃 He added；
to the company generally； 〃Do you know what I think are the two lines of
mine that go as deep as any others； in a certain direction？〃 and he began
to repeat stragglingly certain verses from one of his earlier poems；
until he came to the closing couplet。 But I will give them in full；
because in going to look them up I have found them so lovely； and because
I can hear his voice again in every fondly accented syllable：
〃Who sees unmoved； a ruin at his feet；
The lowliest home where human hearts have beat？
Its hearth…stone； shaded with the bistre stain；
A century's showery torrents wash in vain；
Its starving orchard where the thistle blows；
And mossy trunks still mark the broken rows；
Its chimney…loving poplar； oftenest seen
Next an old roof； or where a roof has been；
Its knot…grass； plantain；all the social weeds；
Man's mute companions following where he leads；
Its dwarfed pale flowers； that show their straggling heads；
Sown by the wind from grass…choked garden…beds；
Its woodbine creeping where it used to climb；
Its roses breathing of the olden time；
All the poor shows the curious idler sees；
As life's thin shadows waste by slow degrees；
Till naught remains； the saddening tale to tell；
Save home's last wrecksthe CELLAR AND THE WELL！〃
The poet's chanting voice rose with a triumphant swell in the climax； and
〃There；〃 he said； 〃isn't it so？ The cellar and the wellthey can't be
thrown down or burnt up； they are the human monuments that last longest
and defy decay。〃 He rejoiced openly in the sympathy that recognized with
him the divination of a most pathetic； most signal fact； and he repeated
the last couplet again at our entreaty； glad to be entreated for it。
I do not know whether all will agree with him concerning the relative
importance of the lines； but I think all must feel the exquisite beauty
of the picture to which they give the final touch。
He said a thousand witty and brilliant things that day； but his pleasure
in this gave me the most pleasure； and I recall the passage distinctly
out of the dimness that covers the rest。 He chose to figure us younger
men； in touching upon the literary circumstance of the past and present；
as representative of modern feeling and thinking； and himself as no
longer contemporary。 We knew he did this to be contradicted； and we
protested； affectionately； fervently； with all our hearts and minds； and
indeed there were none of his generation who had lived more widely into
ours。 He was not a prophet like Emerson； nor ever a voice crying in the
wilderness like Whittier or Lowell。 His note was heard rather amid the
sweet security of streets； but it was always for a finer and gentler
civility。 He imagined no new rule of life； and no philosophy or theory
of life will be known by his name。 He was not constructive； he was
essentially observant； and in this he showed the scientific nature。
He made his reader known to himself； first in the little； and then in the
larger things。 From first to last he was a censor； but a most winning
and delightful censor； who could make us feel that our faults were other
people's； and who was not wont
〃To bait his homilies with his brother worms。〃
At one period he sat in the seat of the scorner； as far as Reform was
concerned； or perhaps reformers； who are so often tedious and ridiculous；
but he seemed to get a new heart with the new mind which came to him when
he began to write the Autocrat papers； and the light mocker of former
days became the serious and compassionate thinker； to whom most truly
nothing that was human was alien。 His readers trusted and loved him； few
men have ever written so intimately with so much dignity； and perhaps
none has so endeared himself by saying just the thing for his reader that
his reader could not say for himself。 He sought the universal through
himself in others； and he found to his delight and theirs that the most
universal thing was often； if not always； the most personal thing。
In my later meetings with him I was struck more and more by his
gentleness。 I believe that men are apt to grow gentler as they grow
older； unless they are of the curmudgeon type； which rusts and crusts
with age； but with Doctor Holmes the gentleness was peculiarly marked。
He seemed to shrink from all things that could provoke controversy； or
even difference； he waived what might be a matter of dispute； and rather
sought the things that he could agree with you upon。 In the last talk I
had with him he appeared to have no grudge left； except for the puritanic
orthodoxy in which he had been bred as a child。 This he was not able to
forgive； though its tradition was interwoven with what was tenderest and
dearest in his recollections of childhood。 We spoke of puritanism； and
I said I sometimes wondered what could be the mind of a man towards life
who had not been reared in its awful shadow； say an English Churchman； or
a Continental Catholic； and he said he could not imagine； and that he did
not believe such a man could at all enter into our feelings； puritanism；
he seemed to think； made an essential and ineradicable difference。 I do
not believe he had any of that false sentiment which attributes virtue of
character to severity of creed； while it owns the creed to be wrong。
He differed from Longfellow in often speaking of his contemporaries。 He
spoke of them frankly； but with an appreciative rather than a censorious
criticism。 Of Longfellow himself he said that day； when I told him I had
been writing about him； and he seemed to me a man without error； that he
could think of but one error in him； and that was an error of taste； of
almost merely literary taste。 It was at an earlier time that he talked
of Lowell； after his death； and told me that Lowell once in the fever of
his anti…slavery apostolate had written him； urging him strongly； as a
matter of duty； to come out for the cause he had himself so much at
heart。 Afterwards Lowell wrote again； owning himself wrong in his
appeal； which he had come to recognize as invasive。 〃He was ten years
younger than I；〃 said the doctor。
I found him that day I speak of in his house at Beverly Farms； where he
had a pleasant study in a corner by the porch； and he met me with all the
cheeriness of old。 But he confessed that he had been greatly broken up
by the labor of preparing something that might be read at some
commemorative meeting； and had suffered from finding first that he could
not write something specially for it。 Even the copying and adapting an
old poem had overtaxed him； and in this he showed the failing powers of
age。 But otherwise he was still young； intellectually； that is； there
was no failure of interest in intellectual things； especially literary
things。 Some new book lay on the table at his elbow； and he asked me if
I had seen it； and made some joke about his having had the good luck to
read it； and have it lying by him a few days before when the author
called。 I do not know whether he schooled himself against an old man's
tendency to revert to the past or not； but I know that he seldom did so。
That morning； however； he made several excursions into it； and told me
that his youthful satire of the 'Spectre Pig' had been provoked by a poem
of the elder Dana's； where a phantom horse had been seriously employed；
with an effect of anticlimax which he had found irresistible。 Another
foray was to recall the oppression and depression of his early religious
associations； and to speak with moving tenderness of his father； whose
hard doctrine as a minister was without effect upon his own kindly
nature。
In a letter written to me a few weeks after this time； upon an occas